How Early Voting and Vote-by-Mail Are Changing Campaigns

The voting landscape has undergone a seismic shift over the past two decades. Early voting and vote-by-mail (VBM) options have transformed how, when, and where Americans cast their ballots. For political campaigns, these changes demand new strategies and approaches to ensure every potential supporter is engaged effectively. As campaigns prepare for elections in this new era, understanding and adapting to these trends is critical for success.

The Evolution of Voting Patterns

In the early 2000s, early voting and absentee ballots were niche practices. For instance, absentee voting in states like Indiana accounted for just 4% of total votes in 2000. Fast forward two decades, and early voting accounts for over half of the votes cast in many states. This change was accelerated by the COVID-19 pandemic, which prompted states to expand VBM options to ensure voter safety.

The availability of early voting varies significantly by state. Some states allow voting as early as six weeks before election day, while others provide only a two-week window. Despite these differences, one trend is consistent: voters are increasingly embracing the convenience of casting their ballots before election day.

Campaign Strategies for Early Voting

Early voting requires campaigns to rethink their voter outreach and engagement plans. A one-size-fits-all approach no longer works when voters are casting their ballots weeks or even months apart. Instead, campaigns must segment their voter base into tranches based on voting behavior.

1. Understanding Voter Behavior:
   
   • Early voters often consist of "super voters"—high-propensity, partisan individuals who rarely miss an election. These voters are not likely to be persuadable, but campaigns can focus on mobilizing them early to lock in support.
2. Tailored Messaging:
   
   • Messaging should differ for early voters, absentee voters, and election-day voters. Early voters may respond better to general party loyalty appeals, while undecided voters closer to election day need issue-specific persuasion.
3. Staging Outreach:
   
   • Campaigns should time their outreach efforts to align with voting windows. This includes sending mailers, running digital ads, and initiating canvassing efforts to coincide with when voters receive their ballots or when early voting begins.

Challenges in the Current Landscape

The widespread adoption of early voting and VBM introduces several challenges for campaigns:

1. State-Specific Laws:
   
   • Each state has unique rules for early voting and VBM. Some allow ballots to be returned weeks in advance, while others have stringent deadlines. Campaigns must navigate these complexities to avoid missteps.
2. Data Management:
   
   • Accurate data is the backbone of any successful campaign. Regularly updated voter files are essential to avoid wasting resources on voters who have already cast their ballots. For example, failing to purge mail or text lists of voters who have already returned their ballots can lead to wasted funds and frustration among supporters.
3. Resource Allocation:
   
   • Early voting requires campaigns to spread their resources over a longer period. This demands meticulous planning to ensure consistent outreach without exhausting budgets too early.

Innovative Approaches to Early Voting

To address these challenges, campaigns are adopting innovative strategies to maximize their impact:

1. Relational Organizing:
   
   • Encouraging early voters to engage their networks is a powerful tool. For instance, campaigns can reach out to early voters with messages like, "Thank you for voting early! Can you help five friends cast their ballots?" Adding gamified incentives, such as recognition or campaign swag, can further motivate supporters to amplify their efforts.
2. Data and Automation:
   
   • Leveraging data analytics and automation tools allows campaigns to fine-tune their outreach. Real-time updates on voter participation help campaigns adjust their strategies and target remaining voters more effectively.
3. Personalized Messaging:
   
   • Campaigns can use survey data and voter modeling to craft messages that resonate with specific segments. For example, older voters who prefer early voting may respond well to messages emphasizing convenience and reliability.
4. Building Name Recognition:
   
   • Down-ballot candidates, in particular, benefit from sustained outreach. Campaigns must ensure that voters recognize their names by the time they fill out their ballots. This requires consistent and repeated exposure through mailers, ads, and other media.

Lessons for Campaigns

The rise of early voting has fundamentally changed the mechanics of political campaigns. To succeed in this environment, campaigns must:

1. Plan Ahead:
   
   • Early voting windows demand early preparation. Campaigns should finalize their strategies and materials well in advance to ensure readiness when ballots drop.
2. Target Strategically:
   
   • Focus on high-value voters who are likely to vote early and use resources efficiently by tailoring outreach to specific segments.
3. Adapt and Innovate:
   
   • Be flexible and willing to experiment with new methods, such as relational organizing or gamified engagement, to mobilize voters effectively.
4. Stay Data-Driven:
   
   • Regularly update voter files and use data insights to guide decision-making. Precision targeting ensures that every dollar spent delivers maximum impact.

Conclusion

The expansion of early voting and VBM is reshaping the electoral landscape. Campaigns that adapt to these trends by embracing nuanced strategies, leveraging data, and fostering engagement will be best positioned for success. By planning ahead and focusing on tailored outreach, campaigns can navigate the complexities of early voting while maximizing their impact.

As early voting continues to grow, campaigns must remain agile and innovative. The future of voter engagement depends on understanding these trends and meeting voters where they are—whether weeks before election day or in the final hours of the race.

Want even more news and insights from the pros who make politics happen? Become a Campaign Trend Insider and unlock exclusive, subscriber-only content every week for just $10 per month. Also remember to subscribe to our YouTube Channel for podcasts and additional content.

‍